Melanie Dean has hosted 30 Episodes.
-
Earth Station Who Episode 400: Why the 4th Doctor Is So Special | Tom Baker Era Deep Dive
March 28th, 2026 | Season 14 | 1 hr 31 mins
classic doctor who podcast, doctor who fan discussion, doctor who fourth doctor era, doctor who podcast discussion, earth station who episode 400, earth station who podcast, eso network, fourth doctor tom baker, mary ogle, melanie dean, michael gordon, mike faber, r alan siler interview, r. alan siler, tom baker, tom baker doctor who episodes, whovian community discussion, why the 4th doctor is special
Celebrate a major milestone with Earth Station Who Episode 400! The crew is joined by author and podcaster R. Alan Siler to explore one of the most beloved eras in Doctor Who history—what makes the Fourth Doctor so special?
Portrayed by the legendary Tom Baker, the Fourth Doctor defined a generation of Doctor Who fans with his iconic scarf, eccentric personality, and unforgettable adventures. In this special 400th episode, we take a deep dive into the Tom Baker era, examining the storytelling, companions, villains, and moments that made this incarnation a fan favorite.
From classic episodes and unforgettable performances to the lasting impact of the Fourth Doctor on the Doctor Who legacy, this discussion celebrates why Tom Baker remains one of the most iconic Doctors of all time. Along the way, we share fan perspectives, behind-the-scenes insights, and plenty of Whovian fun.
-
Earth Station Who Reviews The Girl Who Waited
February 6th, 2026 | Season 13 | 50 mins 3 secs
11th doctor episodes, amy pond, amy pond doctor who, arthur darvill, bbc science fiction, doctor who emotional episodes, doctor who episode review, doctor who fandom, doctor who podcast discussion, doctor who season 6, doctor who the girl who waited, doctor who time travel stories, earth station who podcast, eleventh doctor era, eso network, karen gillan, mary ogle, matt smith doctor who, melanie dean, michael gordon, mike faber, modern doctor who analysis, rory williams, rory williams doctor who, the girl who waited review
The crew of Earth Station Who step into one of the most emotional and thought-provoking adventures of the Eleventh Doctor era as they review “The Girl Who Waited.” Join the team as they explore this powerful Doctor Who episode starring Matt Smith, Karen Gillan, and Arthur Darvill, diving into themes of time, sacrifice, love, and the heartbreaking consequences of the Doctor’s decisions.
From Amy Pond’s unforgettable alternate timeline to Rory’s emotional journey and the moral complexity of the Doctor himself, the Earth Station Who crew break down the story’s sci-fi concepts, character development, and lasting impact on modern Doctor Who. Grab your sonic screwdriver and join the discussion as the team revisits one of the most compelling and emotional episodes of the Eleventh Doctor’s run.
-
The Paternoster Gang: The Casebook of Paternoster Row Review | Doctor Who | Earth Station Who
January 9th, 2026 | Season 13 | 58 mins 16 secs
bbc science fiction, big finish doctor who, dave chapman, doctor who audio adventures, doctor who big finish review, doctor who fandom, doctor who podcast, doctor who review, doctor who spin-off audio, earth station who podcast, eso network, madame vastra jenny flint strax, mary ogle, melanie dean, michael gordon, mike faber, paternoster gang audio drama, the casebook of paternoster row, the paternoster gang big finish
This week on Earth Station Who, the crew trades in the TARDIS for a foggy London streetlamp as we review the Big Finish audio adventure The Paternoster Gang: The Casebook of Paternoster Row—where the monsters are mysterious, the tea is probably poisoned. Someone always knows more than they’re saying.
Starring the unstoppable trio of Madame Vastra, Jenny Flint, and Strax, this collection of Victorian-era mysteries puts the Paternoster Gang front and center without the Doctor to spoil the investigation. From eerie cases to sharp banter (and the occasional explosive misunderstanding courtesy of Strax), we break down the stories, performances, and whether this audio box set delivers proper gothic chills, clever clues, and classic Big Finish fun.
-
Ancient Evil, English Villages & the Fifth Doctor: “The Awakening” Review | Earth Station Who
December 19th, 2025 | Season 13 | 1 hr 13 mins
bbc science fiction, classic doctor who review, dave west, doctor who 1980s, doctor who fandom, doctor who podcast, doctor who review, doctor who season 21, earth station who podcast, eso network, fifth doctor stories, mary ogle, melanie dean, michael gordon, mike faber, peter davison doctor who, phantom troublemaker, tegan jovanka, the awakening doctor who, turlough, whovian geek seat
This week on Earth Station Who, the crew heads back to the Fifth Doctor era to review “The Awakening,” a Doctor Who story that proves nothing good ever comes from ancient legends, spooky English villages, or people saying, “It’s only a myth.”
The Awakening mixes history, folklore, and alien mischief as fear itself becomes the ultimate weapon. We break down the story’s atmosphere, themes, and where it lands among Fifth Doctor adventures—plus whether Saxon curses are ever really a good idea.
We’re also excited to welcome back original Earth Station Who co-host Dave West, who bravely takes a seat in the Whovian Geek Seat. Will his Doctor Who knowledge save him… or will he be sacrificed to the ancient evil?
Expect thoughtful discussion, classic Who love, a few laughs, and plenty of timey-wimey fun as we revisit “The Awakening” on Earth Station Who—where legends never stay buried for long. -
Earth Station Who Reviews “Snare” & “The Last Days of the Powell Estate” – Ninth Doctor & Rose Big Finish Adventures
November 22nd, 2025 | Season 13 | 1 hr 23 mins
bbc science fiction, big finish productions, christopher eccleston doctor who, ciarán moffatt, doctor who audio dramas, doctor who fandom, doctor who podcast, doctor who review, doctor who reviews 2025, earth station who, earth station who podcast, eso network, mary ogle, melanie dean, michael gordon, mike faber, ninth doctor big finish, rose tyler audio adventures, snare big finish review, the last days of the powell estate review
Join the Earth Station Who crew—along with special guest Ciarán Moffatt—as they dive into two powerful Big Finish Doctor Who audio adventures, “Snare” and “The Last Days of The Powell Estate.” In this episode, we explore the dynamic between the Ninth Doctor and Rose Tyler, the emotional depth of these stories, and how they expand the Doctor Who audio universe.
We break down character arcs, storytelling strengths, behind-the-scenes insights, and how these adventures enrich the legacy of the Christopher Eccleston era. Whether you're a longtime Big Finish listener or a fan of Ninth Doctor stories, this discussion is packed with Time Lord-worthy analysis, humor, and deep-cut fandom knowledge.
-
Earth Station Who: The Seventh Doctor Faces the Silver Nemesis
October 31st, 2025 | Season 13 | 1 hr 10 mins
ace, bbc science fiction, british sci-fi podcast, classic doctor who episodes, cybermen, dave chapman, doctor who fandom, doctor who podcast, doctor who review, earth station who, eso network, gallifrey, kirby bartlett-sloan, melanie dean, michael gordon, mike faber, seventh doctor, silver nemesis review, sophie aldred, sylvester mccoy, time lord adventures
In this episode of The Earth Station Who Podcast, the crew travels back to the Seventh Doctor era to review the classic 1988 adventure, “Silver Nemesis.” Join us as we discuss the Doctor (played by Sylvester McCoy) and Ace (Sophie Aldred) taking on the deadly Cybermen, a mysterious comet, and a royal connection that only Doctor Who could deliver! We dive into the story’s production, performances, and its place in Doctor Who history. Grab your bowler hat and umbrella—it’s time for another trip through time with Earth Station Who!
-
Earth Station Who: Revisiting the Fourth Doctor Classic “Planet of Evil”
October 17th, 2025 | Season 13 | 1 hr 12 mins
british sci-fi, classic doctor who episodes, dave chapman, doctor who fandom, doctor who podcast, earth station who, eso network, fourth doctor, melanie dean, michael gordon, mike faber, planet of evil review, rob levy, sci-fi podcast, time lord adventures, tom baker doctor who, whovian geek seat, whovians
In this episode of The Earth Station Who Podcast, the crew travels back to the Tom Baker era to review the Fourth Doctor classic, “Planet of Evil.” Joining the discussion are special guests Dave Chapman and Rob Levy, as they dive into the story’s eerie atmosphere, standout performances, and its place in Doctor Who history. Get ready for a fun and nostalgic journey through one of the darker corners of classic Doctor Who!
-
Earth Station Who: Reviewing Doctor Who – The Second Doctor Adventures: James Robert McCrimmon
October 4th, 2025 | Season 13 | 1 hr 22 mins
big finish doctor who, big finish review, classic doctor who review, doctor who audio dramas, doctor who podcast, earth station who, eso network, frazer hines jamie mccrimmon, james robert mccrimmon, mary ogle, melanie dean, michael gordon, michael troughton doctor who, mike faber, patrick troughton doctor who, podcast review, second doctor adventures
In this episode of Earth Station Who, the crew reviews the Big Finish audio drama Doctor Who: The Second Doctor Adventures – James Robert McCrimmon. Featuring Michael Troughton as the Second Doctor and Frazer Hines reprising his iconic role as Jamie McCrimmon, this release brings Patrick Troughton’s era back to life in thrilling new ways. Join us as we dive into the stories, performances, and legacy of the Second Doctor in Big Finish’s continuing Doctor Who adventures.
-
Earth Station Who Reviews “The Mutants” | Classic Third Doctor Adventure
September 19th, 2025 | Season 13 | 43 mins 18 secs
bbc doctor who, classic sci-fi tv, doctor who commentary, doctor who fans, doctor who podcast, doctor who the mutants, earth station who podcast, eso network, jon pertwee era, mary ogle, melanie dean, michael gordon, mike faber, podcast review, third doctor review, time lord adventures
The Earth Station Who crew takes a trip to the 30th century to unpack the Third Doctor serial The Mutants. From colonial politics and strange transformations to clever Time Lord antics, this episode celebrates Jon Pertwee’s action-packed era. Listen now for lively discussion, fan theories, and plenty of Whovian fun!
-
Doctor Who Review: Daleks in Manhattan & Evolution of the Daleks | Earth Station Who Podcast
September 6th, 2025 | Season 13 | 1 hr 10 mins
dalek episodes doctor who, dalek two-parter, dave chapman, david tennant doctor who, doctor who daleks in manhattan review, doctor who new york episodes, doctor who podcast with guests, doctor who reviews, earth station who podcast, eso network, evolution of the daleks review, mary ogle, melanie dean, michael gordon, mike faber, tenth doctor and martha jones
On this episode of the Earth Station Who Podcast, the crew reviews the two-part Doctor Who story “Daleks in Manhattan” and “Evolution of the Daleks.” Join us as we dive into the Tenth Doctor’s adventures with Martha Jones in 1930s New York, exploring the Daleks’ sinister experiments, classic sci-fi themes, and the story’s place in Doctor Who history. Perfect for fans of the Tenth Doctor and Dalek episodes!
-
Will They Return? Ranking Doctor Who Companions' Chances of a Comeback | Earth Station Who Podcast
August 10th, 2025 | Season 13 | 2 hrs 10 secs
ciarán moffatt, classic doctor who, daniel budnik, doctor who companions, doctor who podcast, doctor who podcast with guests, doctor who returns, doctor who speculation, doctor who tv show, donna noble, earth station who podcast, eso network, mary ogle, melanie dean, michael gordon, mike faber, modern doctor who, returning doctor who characters, susan foreman, tardis crew, whoniverse
In this episode of Earth Station Who, the crew takes a trip through Doctor Who history, discussing the possible return of companions from the classic and modern eras of the show. From Susan Foreman to Donna Noble and beyond, we rank each companion’s likelihood of reappearing in the Whoniverse, whether through cameos, specials, or full story arcs. Join us as we dive into Doctor Who lore, speculate on future returns, and celebrate the characters who have traveled in the TARDIS from the show's beginning to the present day.
-
The War Games in Color: Reviewing the Restored & Shortened Second Doctor Story | Earth Station Who Podcast
July 25th, 2025 | Season 13 | 1 hr 10 mins
1960s doctor who, bbc restoration, classic doctor who, colorized doctor who, doctor who, doctor who history, doctor who podcast, doctor who podcast 2025, doctor who podcast with guests, earth station who, eso network, mary ogle, matthew kresal, mike faber, patrick troughton, reimagined doctor who, sci-fi tv, second doctor, the war games, time lords
On this episode of The Earth Station Who podcast, the crew is joined by Doctor Who author and commentator Matthew Kresal to take a fresh look at the newly restored and colorized version of the classic Second Doctor story, The War Games. With enhanced visuals and a shortened runtime, this reimagined version of the iconic 10-part Doctor Who serial offers a modern perspective on a pivotal chapter in Time Lord history. We discuss Patrick Troughton’s legendary performance, the creative choices behind the restoration and edits, and how the BBC is reintroducing classic stories to new audiences. A must-listen for fans of classic Doctor Who, Second Doctor adventures, and BBC restoration projects.